PG&E settled the Hinkley groundwater claims brought by roughly 650 residents for $333 million on July 2, 1996 — at the time the largest direct-action settlement in U.S. history, and the case dramatized in the film *Erin Brockovich*. The detailed terms were never published, because the deal was struck under a confidential arbitration agreement: no public payment schedule, no public release language, and no allocation showing who received what.
What the money did not do is close the matter. The settlement compensated people; it did not clean up the aquifer, did not cover residents outside the original group, and did not set a finish line for the contamination. Thirty years later, California regulators are still deciding how clean Hinkley's groundwater has to be.
Official resources:
- Read the official notice from Ca — Use this primary source to verify the official announcement.
- Read the original report from Usgs — Use this primary source to review the complete report.
Table of Contents
- What the 1996 settlement actually covered
- Why the case did not end in 1996
- Cleanup was a regulator's job, not a settlement term
- The unresolved question is "how clean is clean"
- Where Hinkley stands now
- Frequently Asked Questions
What the 1996 settlement actually covered
The Hinkley case, *Anderson et al. v. Pacific Gas & Electric*, concerned hexavalent chromium — a form of chromium used as a rust inhibitor in cooling-tower water at PG&E's Hinkley compressor station, and a known human carcinogen when ingested. The company's wastewater ponds let it reach the groundwater beneath the Mojave Desert community. The structure of the resolution matters more than the headline number.
The claims went to binding arbitration, and the first roughly 40 claimants were awarded about $120 million. PG&E then ended the arbitration and settled the remaining claims en masse for $333 million, according to the documented account of the Hinkley groundwater contamination. Extrapolated across 650 people, that is a far lower average per claimant than the arbitrated first tranche. Fees came out of the total. The plaintiffs' firm Masry & Vititoe received $133.6 million, and Erin Brockovich — the law-firm file clerk who found the contamination records and canvassed residents — received about $2.5 million, per EBSCO's summary of the Brockovich–PG&E case. That same confidential-arbitration structure is why the per-plaintiff terms remain unavailable to this day.
Why the case did not end in 1996
Chromium claims against PG&E continued for a decade. In 2006 the utility paid a further $295 million to resolve hexavalent-chromium claims from roughly 1,100 additional people across California, a settlement PG&E described as bringing closure to substantially all outstanding chromium-related claims, as Natural Gas Intelligence reported. That characterization held for about seven years.
On July 19, 2013, a second Hinkley class action was filed in San Bernardino County Superior Court on behalf of residents who had not joined the original case — brought after the contamination plume was found to extend farther than earlier mapping had shown, according to the San Francisco Chronicle. The pattern is the practical lesson for anyone reading this as a comparison case: when the harm is a migrating contaminant rather than a single event, the boundary of the affected class is a moving target. A settlement that is comprehensive on the day it is signed can leave a new group of claimants outside it when the plume maps are redrawn.
Cleanup was a regulator's job, not a settlement term
Neither settlement obligated a cleanup standard. That work sits with the Lahontan Regional Water Quality Control Board, which adopted Cleanup and Abatement Order R6V-2015-0068 on November 4, 2015. The order requires PG&E to define the plume's extent, meet hydraulic capture requirements that stop it spreading, and hit interim concentration targets of 50 parts per billion by December 31, 2025 and 10 ppb by December 31, 2032.
The order has already been tightened once. Amendment R6V-2015-0068-A1, issued May 21, 2024, extended the Area of Allowed Plume Expansion 1,000 feet east while cutting the hexavalent chromium concentration allowed to migrate into that area from 4 ppb to 3.1 ppb, and increased boundary and domestic-well sampling from quarterly to monthly, per the Hinkley Groundwater Remediation Program's August 2024 newsletter. For residents, that split explains an otherwise confusing situation: the litigation is largely over, and the obligations that still shape daily life in Hinkley come from a water board order, enforced through monitoring reports rather than a court judgment.
The unresolved question is "how clean is clean"
The final cleanup standard still does not exist. On July 28, 2026 the Water Board issued Investigative Order R6-2026-0014, directing PG&E to submit a feasibility study evaluating cleanup levels for hexavalent chromium against 13 specified requirements, with a deadline of July 28, 2027 — documented in the program's September 2026 newsletter. The target is "background" — the chromium level that would be present naturally, with no industrial source. That number is itself disputed.
The Lahontan Board's working figure of 3.1 micrograms per liter came from a 2007 study funded by PG&E, while a later USGS investigation sampling about 100 wells put the Hinkley Valley's overall natural background at 3.8 µg/L, ranging from 2.8 µg/L near the compressor station to 4.8 µg/L in the north. That gap is not academic. A lower background figure means more years of pumping, treatment and monitoring; a higher one shortens the obligation. Because the 2015 order's interim targets are keyed to concentration rather than a date certain, the chosen number effectively sets the end of the cleanup.
Where Hinkley stands now
Containment is holding. PG&E's monthly monitoring reports show the plume contained south of Thompson Road, and second-quarter 2026 data indicated no plume migration, with the company proposing a third revision of the hydraulic capture metrics — summarized in the Water Board's October 2026 status of actions.
No public completion date for the cleanup has been set. For readers using Hinkley as a benchmark, a few specifics are worth carrying forward:.
- A confidential arbitration settlement means no public comparables. The $333 million total is known; what any individual received is not, so Hinkley cannot be used to estimate a per-person value.
- Attorney fees were a large share of the gross. $133.6 million of $333 million came off the top before claimants were paid.
- Compensation and remediation are separate tracks. A toxic-exposure settlement typically resolves personal claims; the environmental obligation runs through a state water or environmental agency on its own timeline.
- Regulatory orders are public where settlements are not. The Lahontan orders, monitoring reports and USGS background study are all open records, which is why the cleanup is better documented than the payout.
- "Substantially all claims resolved" is a company statement, not a legal bar. PG&E said it in 2006 and faced a new Hinkley class action in 2013.
Frequently Asked Questions
Did the $333 million settlement require PG&E to clean up the groundwater?
No. Remediation obligations come from the Lahontan Regional Water Quality Control Board's 2015 Cleanup and Abatement Order and its 2024 amendment, not from the settlement.
Why are the individual settlement amounts not public?
The claims were resolved under a confidential arbitration agreement, so the payment schedule and release terms were never disclosed.
Is the Hinkley cleanup finished?
No. As of the Water Board's October 2026 status report the plume is contained south of Thompson Road with no migration recorded in the second quarter of 2026, and no public completion date exists.
What happens after PG&E's 2027 feasibility study?
The study must evaluate cleanup levels against 13 specified requirements, which is the step toward setting a final hexavalent chromium standard for the site.
You Might Also Like
- Sandy Hook Families v. Alex Jones: What Were the Settlement Terms, and What Did They Leave Unresolved?
- Liebeck v. McDonald’s Hot-Coffee Case: What Were the Settlement Terms, and What Did They Leave Unresolved?
- Johnny Depp v. Amber Heard: What Were the Settlement Terms, and What Did They Leave Unresolved?