Johnny Depp and Amber Heard ended the Virginia defamation case with a $1 million payment to Depp and dismissal of appeals by both sides. The agreement kept Depp's June 2022 jury win in place while leaving the conflicting 2020 U.K. ruling unchanged.
A defamation verdict decides whether a false public statement caused compensable harm. A settlement is a private deal that replaces further litigation. Here the deal traded collection of the full award for finality.
Official resource:
- Read the official notice from Etonline — Use this primary source to verify the official announcement.
Table of Contents
- What did the jury award?
- What did the settlement pay and stop?
- What did each side say it meant?
- What stayed unresolved?
- What should damages readers take from this?
What did the jury award?
On June 1, 2022, a Fairfax County jury awarded Depp $10 million in compensatory damages plus $5 million in punitive damages, capped to $10.35 million. The same jury awarded Heard $2 million on her counterclaim, according to NPR in its verdict report.
It concerned a statement by Depp lawyer Adam Waldman calling her claims a "hoax." A compensatory award repays proven loss. A punitive award punishes serious misconduct and is often capped by state law. The gap between the announced $15 million and the entered $10.35 million reflected Virginia's cap.
What did the settlement pay and stop?
On Dec. 19, 2022, Heard announced she would settle rather than continue the appeal she had filed after the June verdict, according to NPR in its settlement report. Both sides had appealed — Heard against the main verdict and Depp against the $2 million counterclaim award.
They ended both appeals through the settlement, as MovieWeb reported. Heard's side would pay $1 million to Depp. Depp's lawyers Benjamin Chew and Camille Vasquez said he pledged to donate it to charities. By June 13, 2023, Heard had paid and Depp split the sum into $200,000 gifts to Make-A-Film, The Painted Turtle, Red Feather, Tetiaroa Society, and Amazonia Fund Alliance, according to Entertainment Tonight in its charity distribution report.
What did each side say it meant?
Entertainment Tonight reported that Depp's lawyers said the jury's unanimous decision and resulting judgment in Depp's favor "remain fully in place" after settlement. NPR reported that Heard said she made "no admission" and called settlement "not an act of concession." She also said there were "no restrictions or gags" on her future voice.
That combination is common in high-profile settlements. The winner keeps the formal win. The payer avoids admitting liability and avoids a speech ban.
What stayed unresolved?
The settlement did not change the 2020 U.K. ruling against Depp, as NPR reported. There a judge found The Sun's "wife beater" claim substantially true and 12 of 14 assault allegations supportable. The U.S. settlement left that finding untouched.
A U.S. jury verdict does not erase a U.K. judgment. Different cases use different claims, evidence, and standards. Readers should not treat the $1 million payment as proof of the full award's collectible value.
What should damages readers take from this?
Headline verdicts often shrink in settlement. Appeals cost time and money.
Final payment may go to third parties rather than the plaintiff. Anyone weighing a defamation or injury claim can use this case to ask better questions: Ask a lawyer to compare the collectible judgment, appeal risk, and tax treatment of any charity payment before accepting a discount.
- What is the entered judgment after caps?
- What will an appeal cost versus a discounted payment now?
- Does the deal require an admission, gag terms, or charity payment?
- Will a ruling in another forum still stand?