Liebeck asked McDonald's for about $20,000 to cover her medical bills. A jury set compensatory damages at $200,000, then reduced the award to $160,000 for her 20% fault.
Compensatory damages are money meant to make an injured person whole. In February 1992, 79-year-old Stella Liebeck spilled coffee served at 180–190°F. She suffered third-degree burns over 6% of her body, spent eight days in the hospital, and needed skin grafts plus months of follow-up care, according to the American Museum of Tort Law account American Museum of Tort Law account.
Table of Contents
- What did Liebeck claim before trial?
- What did the jury award?
- What did the $160,000 cover?
- Did the judge change the compensatory award?
What did Liebeck claim before trial?
Before suing, Liebeck sought about $20,000 for medical bills. McDonald's countered with only $800, so the case went to trial, according to NPR NPR report.
That $20,000 request was narrow. It focused on out-of-pocket medical costs, not pain, lost income, or punishment.
What did the jury award?
On Aug. 18, 1994, a Bernalillo County jury found McDonald's liable for selling dangerously hot coffee. It set Liebeck's
Alex Jones: Which Compensatory Damages Were Claimed or Awarded?”>compensatory damages
What did the $160,000 cover?
The $160,000 was meant to restore losses tied to the injury. It covered medical expenses, lost income, pain, suffering, and disability.
Unlike punitive damages, this sum did not punish McDonald's. It aimed to make Liebeck whole.
- Medical expenses from hospitalization, grafts, and follow-up care
- Lost income during recovery
- Pain, suffering, and disability from serious burns
Did the judge change the compensatory award?
No. Trial Judge Robert H. Scott left the $160,000 compensatory award intact.
He cut the separate $2.7 million punitive award to $480,000, leaving a $640,000 post-remittitur judgment, according to CourtDocket CourtDocket case history. Before appeal was decided, both sides reached a confidential post-verdict settlement widely reported as under $600,000. Readers comparing settlements should separate the jury's $160,000 compensatory figure from later punitive cuts and the final private deal.