Informational Only · Not Legal Advice · No Attorney-Client Relationship · Editorial Policy

Liebeck v. McDonald’s Hot-Coffee Case: Were Punitive Damages Available, Limited, or Reversed?

Punitive damages were available and limited in Liebeck v. McDonald's, not reversed.

The jury awarded them, the trial judge cut them, and no appellate court reversed them. Punitive damages are extra payments meant to punish reckless misconduct and deter repeats. The American Museum of Tort Law reports Stella Liebeck, 79, suffered third-degree burns, eight-day hospitalization and skin grafts from 180–190°F coffee in 1992 Tort Museum account.

Table of Contents

What made punitive damages available?

LegalClarity reports the jury heard of more than 700 prior burn complaints before finding punishment was warranted LegalClarity breakdown. It set punitive damages at $2.7 million, about two days of McDonald's coffee sales. That figure tied punishment to company revenue, not only to medical bills.

That link matters for claimants. Prior complaints showed notice of danger. Courts treat repeated notice plus inaction as stronger support for punishment.

Why was compensation reduced for fault?

The Cornell Law School Legal Information Institute states the jury awarded $200,000 in compensatory damages, then reduced that sum to $160,000 Cornell LII summary. It assigned Liebeck 20% comparative fault for the spill.

Compensatory damages are payments meant to cover actual loss, such as medical care. Comparative fault means the award falls by the plaintiff's share of blame. Here the cut was $40,000. That rule can reduce recovery even when the product caused severe harm.

How did the judge limit the award?

CourtDocket reports Trial Judge Robert H. Scott cut punitive damages to $480,000 through remittitur CourtDocket review. That equaled three times the compensatory award, for a $640,000 total.

He still called McDonald's conduct willful, wanton and reckless. Remittitur is a trial-court cut of an excessive jury award. It lowers payment without overturning liability. The headline $2.7 million therefore never became the judgment.

What ended the case and what should claimants track?

According to the Cornell Law School Legal Information Institute, both sides appealed, then settled confidentially before any appellate ruling. According to CourtDocket, Liebeck had sought about $20,000, was offered $800, and settled for a confidential sum reported below $600,000. She never received the $2.7 million.

The Cornell Law School Legal Information Institute explains punitive damages require proof of intentional or wanton and willful misconduct. That high bar limits when punishment is available. These points shape what claimants should track:.

  • Save medical bills and treatment records from day one.
  • Keep proof the business knew of prior burns or complaints.
  • Expect any award to fall by your share of fault.
  • Expect a large jury award can still face a trial-court cut.

You Might Also Like

We use essential cookies to make this site work and remember your preferences. We do not use advertising or analytics cookies. Privacy Policy.