Informational Only · Not Legal Advice · No Attorney-Client Relationship · Editorial Policy

A Pacemaker Recall Affecting Dependent Patients: Does the Conduct Rise From Negligence to Gross Negligence?

For pacemaker-dependent patients harmed in the Boston Scientific Accolade recall, the reported facts support a negligence claim but do not by themselves prove gross negligence. Gross negligence means reckless disregard for safety, an extreme departure beyond ordinary carelessness, and it depends on what the maker knew and when it acted.

A pacemaker-dependent patient has little or no natural heartbeat to fall back on if pacing fails. According to the FDA, a subset of Accolade devices faced increased risk of permanently entering Safety Mode with limited function in the FDA safety communication. Safety Mode is a backup pacing mode meant to keep basic pacing during a fault.

Table of Contents

What failed in these devices?

High battery impedance during higher-power operations can trigger the fault. The device then drops into Safety Mode, where pacing may be limited and unable to meet the patient's needs.

Affected models include Accolade, Proponent, Essentio and Altrua 2 pacemakers plus Visionist and Valitude CRT-Ps. The action started with about 203,000 pre-September-2018 devices in December 2024 and later expanded to over 1.3 million devices with a software mitigation.

Why are dependent patients at greatest risk?

A non-dependent patient may tolerate a brief pacing problem. A dependent patient can lose effective heart rhythm and rate control within seconds.

That loss can cause fainting, collapse from low blood flow, loss of pacing, or death. This is why cardiologists treat Safety Mode entry as an emergency in a dependent patient.

What separates negligence from gross negligence?

Negligence means failure to use reasonable care in design, testing, warnings, or recall timing. Gross negligence requires more: reckless disregard or conscious violation of safety rights, according to the Cornell legal standard. That legal difference affects damages.

Ordinary negligence can support medical costs, lost income, pain and suffering, and wrongful-death losses. Gross negligence can open the door to enhanced or punitive damages where state law allows them. A Class I recall alone does not decide that question. The FDA uses Class I to mean a reasonable probability of serious injury or death, as explained in the FDA recall definitions page.

What facts will matter most for the higher standard?

Plaintiffs will focus on knowledge and timing. Reporting indicates Boston Scientific knew of battery problems for years before the December 2024 recall, which followed about six months after one patient's death. Harm reports also grew. An early tally cited about 832 injuries and 2 deaths, while May 2026 reports cited 4 deaths and 2,557 serious injuries, as reported by Becker's Hospital Review.

Courts will ask whether those signals showed a known dependent-patient danger that drew no timely warning, inspection, design change, or recall. The defense will point to the other side of the record. Boston Scientific later added monitoring and Brady software to detect impedance and reduce ambulatory Safety Mode risk. Judges and juries will weigh that response against the delay and the foreseeability of harm to dependent patients.

What should patients and families document now?

Replacement is an individual medical decision, not an automatic legal step. Doctors weigh infection risk, surgical risk, battery status, dependence, and software protection before recommending early replacement.

  • Confirm the exact pacemaker or CRT-P model and implant date with the cardiology office.
  • Ask whether the device is under the advisory and whether remote or in-clinic impedance monitoring applies.
  • Save emergency visits, fainting episodes, device checks, replacement recommendations, and out-of-pocket costs.
  • Keep the explanted device or ask in writing where it will be preserved after replacement.

You Might Also Like

We use essential cookies to make this site work and remember your preferences. We do not use advertising or analytics cookies. Privacy Policy.