Attorney fees, medical liens and settlement administration cut Stella Liebeck's gross recovery before she kept any money. A contingency fee came off the top, then litigation costs and medical repayments, leaving a net payment far below each headline figure.
Liebeck was 79 when she spilled McDonald's coffee held at 180–190°F in February 1992. The American Museum of Tort Law reports she suffered third-degree burns over 6% of her body, spent eight days in the hospital and had skin grafts (American Museum of Tort Law account). She first asked for about $20,000 for medical bills and related losses, while McDonald's offered $800 before trial.
Table of Contents
- What did the jury award and the judge enter?
- Why did settlement replace those numbers?
- How does a contingency fee reduce the client's share?
- What gets paid, and in what order?
- What can an injured person do before settling?
What did the jury award and the judge enter?
The August 1994 jury set compensatory damages at $200,000 and reduced that amount 20% to $160,000 for Liebeck's comparative fault. It added $2.7 million in punitive damages tied to coffee-sale revenue.
The trial judge then used remittitur, a court order that lowers an excessive jury award. Punitive damages fell to $480,000, three times compensatory damages. The entered judgment totaled $640,000, not about $2.86 million.
Why did settlement replace those numbers?
Both sides appealed, then settled confidentially before the appeal ended. The reported settlement was under $600,000, as described in LegalClarity's case history.
That step matters for payment. A settlement substitutes a negotiated, confidential payment for the jury award and the reduced judgment. Liebeck did not receive the $2.7 million headline or the full $640,000 judgment.
How does a contingency fee reduce the client's share?
A contingency fee is a lawyer's percentage of the recovery, paid only if the client recovers money. The percentage appears in a signed written agreement, often one-third to 40%, with a higher rate after litigation begins.
In practice, that fee comes out first and directly lowers net payment. LegalClarity explains the customary one-third to 40% range in its contingency-fee guide. On a mid-six-figure settlement, the fee alone removes a large block before costs start.
What gets paid, and in what order?
Settlement administration follows a payment order: attorney fees first, then case costs, then medical liens or Medicare reimbursement.
A lien is a provider, insurer or government payer's legal claim to be repaid from the settlement. That order protects the client from unpaid bills, but it also shrinks take-home pay. LegalClarity reports that deductions often consume half or more, leaving a net recovery around 40%–60% of gross (settlement allocation guide).
- attorney fee under the written agreement
- filing fees, records, experts and other litigation costs
- hospital liens, insurer reimbursement and Medicare repayment
- remaining balance paid to the plaintiff
What can an injured person do before settling?
Ask for the fee percentage at signing, during litigation and on appeal. Get the cost total in writing and request updated lien figures before accepting an offer.
Compare gross offers by estimated net, not by headline alone. A higher gross with large liens can pay less than a lower gross with small liens. Keep every medical bill, insurer letter and Medicare notice together so no lien surfaces late.