Informational Only · Not Legal Advice · No Attorney-Client Relationship · Editorial Policy

Liebeck v. McDonald’s Hot-Coffee Case: How Did Expert Testimony Shape Liability and Damages?

Expert testimony — sworn opinion from a qualified specialist — translated coffee heat into burn times and corporate knowledge. That evidence framed the coffee as an unreasonable danger and drove liability and punitive damages. Stella Liebeck, 79, spilled McDonald's coffee in a parked car in Albuquerque on February 27, 1992.

She suffered third-degree burns over 16% of her body. She spent eight days in hospital and needed whirlpool treatment, skin grafts, and long recovery. The Marler Clark Marler Blog account details those injuries in Marler Blog account of the burns.

Table of Contents

Why Did Heat Measurements Drive Defect?

McDonald's corporate rules required coffee brewed at 195-205°F and held at 180-190°F for taste. Plaintiff experts attacked that fixed practice as defective. The Occidental College handout describes that temperature policy in Occidental College handout on coffee temperatures. Burn expert Dr.

Charles Baxter gave the jury a time scale. Shorter time to severe burn meant less chance to avoid injury. Two other specialists backed him. The University of Texas engineering chairman and the editor of the Journal of Burn Care and Rehabilitation each called the scald risk unacceptable. Consumer Attorneys of California report that corroboration as support for defect and negligence.

  • 190°F liquid produces third-degree burns in under three seconds
  • 180°F produces third-degree burns in about 12-15 seconds
  • 170°F causes second-degree burns within 3.5 seconds
  • 160°F takes about 20 seconds

What Did Company Records Show?

Quality-assurance supervisor Christopher Appleton admitted McDonald's knew hot coffee caused serious burns. The Occidental College handout reports about 700 burn complaints over 10 years. The company still enforced the 180-190°F holding rule.

The same testimony said McDonald's had no plan to lower heat or warn about severe burns. That inaction let plaintiff experts link knowledge to choice. Knowledge plus no change supported negligence, which means failure to use reasonable care.

Why Was Liebeck Found 20% at Fault?

Comparative fault means the jury divides responsibility between plaintiff and defendant. Defense experts argued burns were statistically rare against billions of cups served. Consumer Attorneys of California note that rarity argument.

The defense also argued burns could occur even at much lower temperatures. The jury still assigned Liebeck 20% fault for the spill. That share reduced her compensation but did not defeat the defect claim.

How Did Testimony Translate Into Dollars?

The August 1994 jury found McDonald's 80% at fault. It awarded $200,000 in compensatory damages, money to repay medical harm and loss, then cut the sum to $160,000 for Liebeck's 20% share.

The FindLaw summary records that split and reduction in FindLaw summary of the verdict. Punitive damages, money meant to punish and deter, added $2.7 million. That sum equaled about two days of McDonald's coffee revenue. Expert proof of known danger and many prior burns gave the jury a basis for punishment, not just repayment.

Why Did the Headline Number Not Get Paid?

The trial judge cut punitive damages to $480,000, three times the compensatory award, for a $640,000 total. The Round Table Group review explains that judicial reduction and later settlement in Round Table Group review of the post-trial reduction.

The parties then made a confidential post-verdict settlement. The headline $2.7 million was never paid. For a burn claim, preserve what experts need:.

  • Keep the container, lid, and receipt
  • Photograph the injury and healing stages
  • Save hospital, graft, and therapy records

You Might Also Like

We use essential cookies to make this site work and remember your preferences. We do not use advertising or analytics cookies. Privacy Policy.