Punitive damages were available in Dominion Voting Systems v. Fox News, but they were never limited or reversed. Punitive damages, extra money meant to punish serious misconduct and deter repetition, were expressly on the table, yet no jury awarded any amount because the case settled before a verdict.
US Dominion Inc. sued Fox News Network LLC and Fox Corp. in Delaware Superior Court in March 2021 over false claims that Dominion rigged the 2020 election. Recording Law reports the suit sought about $1.6 billion in the case that ended with a $787.5 million settlement (Recording Law case summary).
Table of Contents
- What did Dominion seek?
- How did the judge treat falsity and damages?
- Why did no jury decide punitive damages?
- What does the settlement mean for damages tracking?
What did Dominion seek?
Dominion sought punitive and economic damages for defamation per se. Defamation per se means a false statement so serious that harm is presumed. That pleading choice placed punitive damages within the case from the start.
The demand framed the trial stakes around both loss and punishment. Economic damages would address business harm. Punitive damages would address punishment for alleged misconduct.
How did the judge treat falsity and damages?
On March 31, 2023, Judge Eric M. Davis granted Dominion partial summary judgment on falsity. The Delaware Superior Court opinion ruled as a matter of law that the 20 disputed statements about Dominion were false (Delaware Superior Court opinion).
Actual malice remained for trial. Malice here means knowledge of falsity or reckless disregard for truth. The court called damages intensely factual and left damage values, including punitive damages, to the jury.
Why did no jury decide punitive damages?
Jury selection finished and opening statements were set to begin on April 18, 2023. Fox then agreed to pay Dominion $787.5 million to resolve the lawsuits. Poynter reported the last-minute deal ended the trial before any verdict (Poynter's settlement report).
Fox stated it acknowledged the court's rulings finding certain claims about Dominion to be false. That concession addressed falsity. It did not create a malice finding or a damages award.
What does the settlement mean for damages tracking?
Because the $787.5 million was a negotiated settlement, no jury awarded punitive damages. A settlement payment is not divided by a court into compensatory and punitive parts.
So there was nothing for an appeals court to limit or reverse. Readers who track awards should separate settlements from verdicts: The SEC filing record shows Fox disclosed the payment in its April 18, 2023 Form 8-K. Check that filing and the trial docket before citing the $787.5 million as a punitive-damages verdict.
- check whether punitive damages were pleaded
- check whether the judge left them to the jury
- check whether a jury awarded them or the parties settled
- check company disclosures for the settlement amount and form